Saturday, December 14, 2019

BEYOND DESPAIR


BEYOND DESPAIR

By Van Nguyen

  


Severe[ house after North Vietnamese topers seized the Independence Palace Saigon; flags of the Front for the Liberation of South Vietnam were seen flying here and there in the streets of Saigon. The Saigon Radio incessantly aired chants and praises singing the Great Spring Victory, the heroic exploits of the revolutionary armed forces defeating the enemy and liberating the people from the yoke of the “American imperialism and the puppet government.” North Vietnamese troopers in green uniforms inundated military headquarters and public departments, agencies and offices. Within days, the Military Admiration Commission seized control, reestablished the order in the city. A week later, Ha Phu Thuan, a high official of the Privy Revolutionary Government from the R Central Headquarters, was seen on assignment to conduct affairs at the old Ministry for the Interior on Tu Do Street. North Vietnamese troopers, and not the black-clothes fighters of the Privy Revolutionary Government of the Republic of South Vietnam, were on guard around the Ministry buildings. Rumors spread, saying that fighters in the Front for the Liberation were almost all eliminated from the battleground after their retreat from Saigon following the Tet Offensive in 1969.    

Within days, volunteers with red armed bands appeared at cross-roads, avenues, and streets, directed circulation of vehicles, and kept order. A new system of administration was established   at the city precincts, wards, and streets. Military Administration Committees occupied precinct headquarters and ward offices. Troopers assisted by undercover during the Vietnam War seized control and directed public affairs. Volunteers, mostly the “revolutionary of April [1975]”—the opportunists--, secured services at streets cells. Volunteers helped local authorities with directing and controlling daily public services. The head of “to an ninh” (security street-cell) was particularly entrusted with reporting on the daily activities of all households in the street. Every decision was decided upon by “the authorities at upper levels,’ however.   

The military personnel and public servants in the old regime were classified into different categories. Those that were classified into the categories of “the blood debtors to the people and the “Revolution’ were either  subject to punishment without trial or sent to prisons or reeducation camps for long-term detention. The high rank- and-file personnel of the “puppet administration” were to report at various headquarters or stations to be scheduled for reeducation. Lowest level employees working for the puppet administration, even an office cleaner, could have involuntarily contributed to the service for the “American imperialism and the puppet administration.” All of them were also to be reeducated to repent on their mistakes and errors. They were likely to be redeemed under the policy of tolerance and leniency of the “Revolution.” Non-commissions and soldiers and low-level public servants in the old regime were to report at ward offices for the on-the-spot reeducation. They then had a sense of the generosity and clemency of the “Revolution.” They had the obligation to attend sessions of thought reforms, confessed crimes, if any, and mistakes and errors. Upon completion, they would be likely given absolution and the right to the citizenship. They would then be legally entitled to contributing to the socialist contribution.

Reality proves the reverse. Servicemen in the Armed Forces of the Republic of Vietnam are all “pirates.” Never have they been treated as citizens. Right on April 30, 1975, South Vietnam wounded soldiers across of the country, even they were on death beds, were turned out of hospitals. There is no policy for these disabled soldiers. Neither is there a policy of tolerance, clemency, and lenience in this regard. These “pirates’ are seen as outlaws, and they are treated as the “enemies to the people.” Hundreds thousand veteran disabled soldiers and servicemen and their family members have been preyed to poverty and misery. Quite a few of them drag out a miserable existence at the mercy of generous benefactors and passers-by on the sidewalks of townships and cities.
      
As soon as troopers came in and seized control at public departments, agencies, and offices, the new regime summoned on public radios all the rank-and-file personnel of the old regime to report at offices to continue routine service.  Only several days later, high officials and officers in the army or the security service from the rank of second-lieutenant and higher were to register for reeducation at designated public headquarters or stations for reeducation. Employees at lower levels were told to register for on-the-spot reeducation at local offices or simply sent home for further decision. Guardians or door-keepers were kept for temporary service. Within days, almost all central and local departments, offices, institutions of the old administration were subject to dissolution. Hundreds of thousand employees of the old regime in Saigon were in an instant out-of-work and didn’t know what would happen to them in the days to come.     

  Cadres and officials of all branches, trades, and services—professional, non-professional personnel and undesirable elements-- from the North flowed to fill in the vacant positions at various central and local departments, agencies, and offices of the old administration. Tumultuous waves of cadres, officials, guerrillas, and unidentified elements from the “liberated zones” in the South-- Ca Mau, Chau Doc, Rach Gia, An Giang, Tay Ninh, Ben Tre, Kien Phong, Cu Chi, Binh Long, and so on- were brought in the “newly-liberated” provinces, townships, and cities to fill in vacant positions at public precinct and ward headquarters and offices. They assumed the executive role, regulating public services. Officials and police officers from the North, in particular, were in charge of the direction and supervision. Newly-selected servicemen and the guerrillas from the “liberated zones “ were then seen in yellow uniforms to direct circulation of vehicles and kept order in replacement of the “revolutionaries of the April 30” and red arm-band volunteers. Elsewhere, in the Center and the Central Highlands, similar campaigns for pacification were carried on to reestablish public security and order.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 

Teachers and professionals in the domain of education were given special treatment. The then Minister of Education Nguyen Van Hieu declared: “Teachers are not pirates.” Nevertheless, educational public and private educational institutions, establishments. and schools were subject to restructure. Private educational institutions, establishments, and schools were confiscated, and their right to the ownership of property was transferred to the people. They were therefore, subject to dissolution. Thousands of members in the teaching staffs were sent home. They were allowed, nevertheless, to attend reeducation classes to reform thought and to understand the policies of the “Revolution.” Like their colleagues in the public educational services in the old regime, they might be selected to serve the new regime.

The processes for reeducation were phased in unforeseen periods of time. Programs were scheduled for teachers to attend on-the-spot reeducation classes. The term of classes varied depending on the availability of instructors at each locality and the decisions of the local authorities in charge. Teachers at lower levels attended short terms reeducation. Professors and experts at higher institutions and university, especially professors and experts in the humanities and social sciences at private institutions, attend longer terms of reeducation. At the old Ministry for the Interior, during the first days of the “liberation,” experts, officials, and professors at the “Vien Tu Nghiep Quoc Gia” (National Institute of Training), for instance, were to report at the old National Assembly for reeducation at camps. The low-level personnel were assembled at the offices for a three-day thought reform class. Thought reform sessions focused on the denunciations of crimes of “My-Nguy” (American Imperialism and the puppet government). Attenders were called to repent on their own crimes, if any, or mistakes and errors they had made against the “Revolution.” Thereupon, they were given pardon but dismissed from service. Hope for continuation of employment under the new regime dissipated, but they felt self-assured for having not committed a “crime.”  

    Thought reform for the intelligentsia of Saigon was scheduled to take place at higher educational institutions of the old regime, at the Saigon Faculty of Medicine in Cho Lon (Saigon Chinatown) and the National Institute for Public Administration in Saigon, for instance. These preparations proceeded amid the tumultuous campaigns for defeating the reactionary bourgeoisie and mercantile compradors, and thus attracting a large attendance. Some came out of curiosity. Others were fearful of being attributed to as reactionaries. Still, hopefuls were optimistic enough that they might be selected for employment, having completed reeducation.

      The audience were reeducated in the eulogies for the glory of the “Revolution,” the great leadership  of the Party, and the heroic achievements of the Vietnamese people in the fight for the liberation of the people from the yoke of “American imperialism and the puppet administration” in South Vietnam. Instructors and cadres elaborated barbarous and atrocious war crimes by the enemies, the phony prosperity, and the debauchery of the life under the old regime. Severest fights during the Vietnam War, Dong Xoai (Phuoc Timh), Cu Chi (Gia Dinh), An Loc (Binh Long), Khe Sanh (Central Highlands), were exemplified as the victorious achievements of the over the enemies .       
      
     In 1977, an official thought reform program was especially designed for the intelligentsia in Saigon. Again, intellectuals from various areas of culture and education were called on to attend. Particular groups were, again, assembled at various locations, mostly at higher educational institutions in Saigon. Teaching staffs and the personnel in the humanities and social sciences at private higher institutions and universities, for instate, reassembled at the Faculty of Medicine, Minh Duc University, Saigon. Classes operated from Monday to Friday. The attenders were educated in Marxism-Leninism, with concentration on the workings of the doctrine in all domains of the political and economic life. Democratic centralism is million times greater than the American democracy. Invincible socialism gloriously wins over capitalism. Social justice is for everyone under the leadership of the Communist Party, the representative of the workers and the working class. The “Revolution” gives pardon to all who repent on their errors and mistakes. Everyone should contribute to the cause of “the Revolution.”

   Sessions of study were conducted under the direction of cadres from the North. There is no limit of time for complete reeducation. It takes a lifetime. Successful thought reform depends on the individual’s will and wishes. The thought reform program terminated after an eighteen-month study. Hopefuls for selected employment were told to continue activities in assembly at the “Hoi Tri Thuc Yeu Nuoc” (Association for Patriotic They were encouraged to join in socialist economic production—to learn practices for labor production, digging canals at the pilot agricultural farms at the swampy areas of Thai My, Cu Chi, and Binh Hoa and on the barren Nguyen Van Coi fields. After months of waiting, several hopefuls were selected for employment on recommendations, mostly from competent cadres and officials in the new administration. Others voluntarily dismissed themselves from assembly at the association headquarters in reluctance. Selected recruits for employment were a few. They were paid from 50 to 60 dong a month. With 1 dong, they could buy a piece of bread of about 200 grams. They seemed to be self-satisfied with their lot. They and their family members would not be sent the new economic zone for socialist production, at the least.             

Thursday, November 21, 2019

CORRUPTION


CORRUPTION

By Van Nguyen

    

Corruption became a serious disease following the` takeover of South Vietnam. In June 1976, after the “de facto” though shortly before the “de jure” reunification, Communist Party Secretary-general  Le Duan, once again, castigated the party cadres for bribery, misappropriation of private property, and various other corrupt practices. In April 1977, the Party Secretary-general signed a Politburo resolution to heighten vigilance against corruption. It blamed State cadres and officials for abuse of power and corrupt practices. Rectifications followed in 1977, and anticorruption campaigns were activated accordingly. Several cadres and officials were expulsed from the Communist Party. However, corruption was increasingly pervading throughout the officialdom the following years. The Party leadership perceived that the problem was   alarmingly and sought for measures to halt it.

  In September 1983, after successive anti-corruption campaigns, a new Central Department for Internal Affairs was created to reinforce the task. Nevertheless the objective was not fully defined. It primarily focused on the relief of the Party Central Committee of Internal Affairs’ anti-corruption organs from collapse. The new organ, in its turn, failed to carry out its task, nevertheless.  In the early summer of 1983, the Party Central Committee issued a clearer statement according to which Party cadres were no longer permitted to own land, especially cadres on assignments in the administration in South Vietnam--22 per cent of whom were working at the district level or higher disposed of assets in the way decreed by the central authorities revealed as insensitivity and nativity. (Leslie Homes, 1993, p.187) 

 Instances of corruption were volubly numerous. Campaigns for fighting against it multiplied. Reports in various forms on corruption and abuses of power of individual cadres for personal interests accumulated. The report in the Vietnamese media in November 1984 is a classic example of how an individual can simultaneously practice serial corruption. The director of the public security in Dong Nai Province, Captain Nguyen Huu Gioc, engaged in various kinds of corruption during the period of 1979-83. He released ‘reactionaries’ from re-education centers, and then found them posts in government offices--all paid in return with bribes. He even secured the release of a former adviser to former President Thieu of South Vietnam when the man was arrested on charge of reactionary crime in return with a bribe. He extorted gold and money from a Chinese ethnic, who sought to flee Vietnam. He even distributed cross-border smuggling permits. Higher officials knew of Nguyen’s activities and tried to expose his crimes to light. Nguyen’s response was to draw up false reports to refute accusations, claiming that they are false. (Vietnam News Agency, November 9, 1984).

The fight against corruption reached momentum. At the end of 1984, the Communist Party, at a Party conference, prepared for a major campaign for eradication of the “negative phenomena.” It was chaired by the then Head of the Security Ministry and Politburo member Pham Hung. The five negative phenomena included the four issues related to abuse of power and corruption was given careful considerations. They were specifically enumerated as smuggling, financial speculation, bribery, and loaning money at high interest rates. Again, anti-corruptions campaigns began and continued well into 1986, even within the circle of the Party apparatchik and the legal institutions, being the two groups singled out for particularly vehement attacks. Ordinary citizens were encouraged to criticize acts of retrogression via letters to the press. In one weekend, about 1,300 letters arrived at the Ho Chi Minh City newspapers. In these letters, the second most criticized aspect of life in modern Vietnam. It is mostly on the poor side of the ailing economy, as a consequence of corrupt officialdom. At the Sixth Congress of the Vietnamese Communist Party, held in December 1986, the assembly tackled corruption and identified it as one of the Party’s major tasks for rectification.  (Beresford, 1988: 84).

Corruption became a national scourge, but the administration came up with no practical solution.  From the early to the mid-1980, the Communist administration intensified its fight against corruption. Nevertheless, high authorities were spared from “washing dirty linen in public.”  Politburo member Le Duc Tho, in an article in the official daily “Nhan Dan,” in May 1986, acknowledged that “in this second stage, the challenge has been faced with material temptation, bourgeois lifestyle, money, beautiful girls, and luxurious commodities. Retrogression gradually dissipates the best qualities and ethics of a revolutionary. It destroys in secret the strength of our contingent. Ideologically speaking, complex developments are being identified among cadres and party-members. Corruption, bribery, and smuggling are a phenomenon. This situation is existent everywhere and at every echelon. It causes great losses to public properties and the people’s material life. It degrades the cadres and party members, and it denudates the public’s confidence. It may be said that, in our Party, there has been no such a degeneration of virtues ever before. This is a major and serious issue.”    

In August 1987, an article published in the Party’s theoretical political journal “Hoc Tap” (Studies) denounced with analysts on the indecent conduct of public affairs of the Politburo member To Huu and a number of party functionaries for their corrupt practices. Corruption remained a critical issue. Corrupt practices were exposed on the official media. Reports on the military’s misusing of socialized property in Ho Chi Minh City, for instance, was published in the daily “Saigon Giai Phong” (Saigon Liberated), January 10 1988. The publication of the case might be part of the campaign designed to bring the Vietnamese military under control. Phan Van Thanh, one of  accomplices of the Twenty-eighth Convalescence Group that used military vehicles to hinder people from escaping Vietnam in exchange for bribes-- 20 taels of gold each person. Phan was tried by a military tribunal and sentenced to 12 years’ imprisonment. His accomplices received the sentences ranging from three years to 11 years in prison  

Complaints over social insecurity are heard everywhere, in the cities and the countryside as well. Nguyem Xuan Thieu, a high school teacher of geography and history under the old regime who retired to his home village in Binh Duong groaned: “Social corruption grieves me.  I survive poverty on my own labor.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Although old and Weak, I still labor miserably to subsist. Robbers and malefactors rule the village I raised a chicken and lost it. I raised a rabbit, it was swiped. There is no law and order. I would be unavoidably tripped off a piece of furniture by a hamlet official if he insistently wants to take it. The piece of land I am allocated is always preyed to confiscation for the State’s use any moment. Life here is happy if one is spared from theft, piracy, and corruption.  Grumbles as such are familiar to anyone with knowledge of Vietnam today. To be fair, local authorities are aware of these social evils, but turn a blind eye to it. 

Corruption linked to abuse of power is a serious problem. Georges Duhamel, a French writer, noted that “a senior Communist told city officials in Hanoi that fighting against corruption should be the top priority. Throughout the country, as many as 74 communal officials have been assigned on mission to carry on the fight against corruption. A high official with a State company has just been given the life sentence for embezzlement of $US 30,000 dollars.” (Georges Duhamel, the Post-revolution Vietnam. Doan Ket. No.338. Jan. 1988, pp. 36-37).

    The State condemnation on and the press campaigns for elimination of crimes initiated by the authorities continued all through the later years of the 1980’s. In his Lunar New Year speech of February 1988 published in the daily “Nhan Dan”, April 8, 1988, Politburo member Nguyen Van Linh listed five main tasks for 1988, the last of which was the urgency of the purification of the Party and the officialdom, weeding out degenerate and degraded elements, regardless of their ranks and positions. The daily acknowledged that “It is a matter of concern that the elimination should concentrate on party members and cadres at the highest echelon. Their indecent conduct is covered up in one way or another. Party, State, and police officials are tantamount to committing corrupt practices. Crimes as such impair the prestige of the Party and State should be brought to court. Crimes of infringements on the Party discipline and the law should be severely punished to consolidate the people’s confidence in the Party.”  On June 9, 1988, the same official daily reported that more than 500 members of the Communist Party in Cao Bang Province had been expelled from the Party while another 391 had been subjected to “disciplinary action” for embezzlement and other abuses of power. This was another achievement following the “purification campaign” directed by the administration.

  Social evils were rampant as a result of corrupt practices. The daily “Nhan Dan,” in August 2, 1988, acknowledged in bitter terms that, as of the end of 1987, there were 6,845 thefts of public proprieties valued at 1,320,700,000 dong, and 60% of the speculators were state cadres. Sixty-five percent of the soldiers discharged from military services could not find jobs. Robberies in broad daylight increased daily. Juvenile delinquency was another major problem. Previously, reports from the security police admitted that the statistics collected in 1979 revealed that 15,511 teenagers committed crimes, were addicts to drugs, and victims of prostitution.   

In January 1989, in a speech delivered at Vinh Phu, Truong Chinh heightened vigilance on the disrespect of social law and order, referring to the widespread corruption among cadres and party members. Official report on the instance of corruption in Cao Bang made a topic in the press. Members of the Party committee of the province had stolen large quantities State properties. The situation became so critical that Party Secretary-general Nguyen Van Linh unwillingly ordered a clamp-down on media reports and criticism on negative phenomena, including corruption. The active participation of the media crimes revelations had been undermining the prestige and credibility of the Communist Party of Vietnam. The measure was strongly endorsed by the Vietnamese Communist Party. It was not until its seventh plenum in August 1989 that the leadership, again, appealed to Party cadres and officials for resolute anti-corruption actions. The appeal appeared to be unconvincing, however (Le Dinh Dieu, Interview with Nguyen Minh Can. VNCR February 20, 1998).